Hello HoopBallers,
This is the official Rate My Trade thread for the 2022-2023 NBA season.
Use this thread to get the opinion and advice of our pros and community about the trades you made, the trades you are considering or the trades that happened on your leagues.
Make sure to let us know what type of league you are playing and any other details that you find important to allow us to evaluate and comment on your trades.
- 9 cats H2H league
- Trade offered, his bradley Beal for my Myles turner.
- I punt 3s, TO
- what do u think?
I think I'd prefer Myles in a vacuum, and with a punt 3's it doesn't change things much since neither guy is overwhelmingly a 3pt shooter. Obviously Myles carries you in blocks, solid in boards without Sabonis around... I guess it comes down to whether you want to probably consider punting blocks and leaning more into a guard build
Trade Conley for RJ Barret? 12T9catH2H
Trade Conley for RJ Barret? 12T9catH2H
Not in category leagues, god no. Points leagues, yes. Category no.
Hey! 16 team H2H 9 cat league. Punt-ish PTS with a desire to increase FG%. I think of proposing below trade:
I receive: Jokic, Markkanen, Tyler Herro
I send: Durant, Rozier, Wendell Carter Jr.
I think Durant can be#1 on average this year but there is always the injury concern. Maybe this is not Jokic's year? I know he is still a beast but not as much as last two years. Do you think he will bounce back? So yeah, what do you think I should do?
Appreicate the support! Thanks for this great forum!
Hey! 16 team H2H 9 cat league. Punt-ish PTS with a desire to increase FG%. I think of proposing below trade:
I receive: Jokic, Markkanen, Tyler Herro
I send: Durant, Rozier, Wendell Carter Jr.
I think Durant can be#1 on average this year but there is always the injury concern. Maybe this is not Jokic's year? I know he is still a beast but not as much as last two years. Do you think he will bounce back? So yeah, what do you think I should do?
Appreicate the support! Thanks for this great forum!
I feel like you see a bounce in FG% and assists, though you don't lose THAT many points since Herro is a high scorer. I dunno, feels like you're shuffling deck chairs. If you want to punt points I'd aim for someone coming back that's not Herro.
Trade my Fox for PG13? 12T9catH2H
My Lowry for his Jamal Murray? 8T 9cat
In a 14 team 8 cat Roto 4 man keeper.
I get
Kawhi Leonard ($9 - 1.5 seasons before extension)
Jamal Murray ($7 - 1.5 seasons before extension)
I give
Damian Lillard ($40 - 2.5 seasons before extension)
Marcus Morris ($1 - 2.5 seasons before extension)
Do I take it? Hold Dame since he’s the best player involved? Try and wait until Kawhi is back…?
Trade my Fox for PG13? 12T9catH2H
Yeah gimme PG
My Lowry for his Jamal Murray? 8T 9cat
Yeah I'll take the shot on Jamal goin' nutso
In a 14 team 8 cat Roto 4 man keeper.
I get
Kawhi Leonard ($9 - 1.5 seasons before extension)
Jamal Murray ($7 - 1.5 seasons before extension)
I give
Damian Lillard ($40 - 2.5 seasons before extension)
Marcus Morris ($1 - 2.5 seasons before extension)
Do I take it? Hold Dame since he’s the best player involved? Try and wait until Kawhi is back…?
Man ... now obviously the price you're getting on Kawhi/Jamal is excellent, but if you're trying to win THIS YEAR Kawhi is just so scary, and who knows if he's ever quite the same again. I think I have to pass. Dame is too good to give up for something so scary.
Got offered Zach Lavine for my Jakob Poeltl and Jamal Murray. 9cat 10t, I'm leaning towards holding onto jamal and jakob, but what do you guys think?
Thanks!
The LaMelo team owner in my league has made me two offers today.
H2H Points League
Offer 1: LaMelo Ball(2 games, 39.8) and Khris Middleton(has yet to play) for my Mitchell(66.8) and Michael Porter Jr.(38.7)
Offer 2: LaMelo Ball and Khris Middleton for my Devin Booker(56.5) and Franz Wagner(39.5)
I've started 3-1 in the league so I can afford some patience with Middleton. Which one should I take? Or should I?
Got offered Zach Lavine for my Jakob Poeltl and Jamal Murray. 9cat 10t, I'm leaning towards holding onto jamal and jakob, but what do you guys think?
Thanks!
I think I might take it. Zach's like a safe version of Jamal and in 10-teamers clearing out a roster spot is quite valuable.
The LaMelo team owner in my league has made me two offers today.
H2H Points League
Offer 1: LaMelo Ball(2 games, 39.8) and Khris Middleton(has yet to play) for my Mitchell(66.8) and Michael Porter Jr.(38.7)
Offer 2: LaMelo Ball and Khris Middleton for my Devin Booker(56.5) and Franz Wagner(39.5)
I've started 3-1 in the league so I can afford some patience with Middleton. Which one should I take? Or should I?
Offer 2 is CLOSE, but I think I'd rather just leave the 2nd piece out on both sides. Though I guess if you can stomach, say, 2 weeks of Middleton being out, that would be a pretty good win by December 1.
