Last Updated on March 27, 2025 4:43 pm by André Lemos | Published: August 13, 2024

In today’s pickups, we have a starter who looks good coming back from Tommy John surgery, a bullpen arm about to take over the closer’s role for a top team and a bat who is getting overlooked by the vast majority of fantasy managers.

Tyler Mahle – SP – TEX – 22% Yahoo, 46% Fantrax

After only getting 25.2 innings in under his belt in 2023, he got Tommy John surgery and has been out until now. He has made two starts and has looked pretty good.

H has a 2.79 ERA with nine strikeouts in 9.2 innings to just four walks. In 2023, he started the year with a 3.16 ERA and a 3.23 xERA and 3.65 xFIP. While in 2022 he had an inflated ERA of 4.40, he had a 3.49 xERA.

Overall, his ERA and ERA estimators always seem to be around the 3.50-4.00 range between 2020-24.

He also has a strikeout rate between 25% and 28% in those years and he flashed very good swing and miss stuff in his last outing, earning 15 whiffs and a stellar 32% CSW.

While Mahle is not an elite arm, he is a solid middle-of-rotation arm in fantasy and needs to be given a look by 12-teamers as a stream and is a solid add in deeper formats

League size recommendation: 12-team league streamer, 14-team league add.

Want to get access to the rest of Paul’s article? You’ll need to have a FANTASYPASS membership. Click here to learn more and sign up!
Premium Access Required

Click here to join us on Discord! And Follow us on Twitter by clicking here
Come join us at SportsEthos by filling out an application by clicking here
Follow Paul at @PaulW_34

• About the Author
• Latest Posts

Paul Williamson

I grew up in Crosby, TX, just about 30 minutes east of Houston, TX. Yes, I am a major Houston Astros fan, and love my Texans and Rockets.

I graduated Crosby High School in 2006 (Go Coogs!) and attended San Jacinto College (Go Gators!) before attending and graduating from Texas Tech in 2012 (Go Tech!). I got my degree in journalism.

Throughout my academic life I was on some form of debate team, and it was the greatest experience of my academic career.

Now I couldn’t be more happier. Sports Ethos is allowing to me to live a life long dream: to be a sports writer.

• 2026 Fantasy Baseball Season in Review - Middle Infield Duds
• Fantasy MLB Today: Fantasy Baseball 2026 Middle Infield Breakouts
• Fantasy MLB Today: Fantasy Baseball Middle Infield Studs & Duds
• 2026 Fantasy Baseball Season in Review - Outfield Studs
• Fantasy MLB Today: 2026 Fantasy Baseball Year in Review - Buy or Sell Outfield Breakouts?