Fantasy Baseball Strategy Guide – Roto Leagues

​
  • Rotisserie fantasy leagues (more commonly referred to as ‘roto’ leagues), are likely the most popular format for fantasy baseball.

    In this format, teams compete against each other in a season-long marathon. Scoring is based on where teams rank in the determined categories.

    The standard categories, known as 5X5, count batting average, runs scores, RBI, home runs and stolen bases for hitting. For the pitchers, the categories are ERA, WHIP, wins, saves and strikeouts.

    In a standard 12 team league, managers will earn 12 roto points for getting first in a category. 11 will be given to second, 10 to third and all the way to just 1 point for 12th.

    The team with the most points at the end of the year is the winner.

    So. why roto?

    It helps mitigate the randomness of baseball.

    Not completely as baseball’s beauty does come from its unpredictability.

    But if a pitcher’s start gets pushed back from the weekend to a Monday or Tuesday, it matters very little in a roto league as those stats will count towards a season-long total, not a one-off week like we have in head-to-head formats. That starter’s start being pushed back would cause a team being tagged with more losses in a head-to-head league.

    In head-to-head leagues, that league’s title is determined during the season’s waning weeks and that is very risky and unpredictable way to determine a league’s winner.

    A team could be filled with dominant players and absolutely destroy their competition all year.

    Then, come title week, their best hitter gets plunked on the wrist and misses four games.

    That ace on a contending team set to start late in the week has their start pushed back as the team starts to line up their rotation for key matchups.

    Or they start to manage the workloads of their players on rebuilding teams.

    The playoff race causes more randomness that can tank the best team for just one week and bam, they lose the title.

    None of this happens in a roto league and it does not matter when the player accumulates their stats.

    Draft strategy – The early rounds

    In the first few rounds, it is critical that managers target players with legit four-to-five category production.

    These are not the rounds to target that 40-steal player with mediocre average and no power.

    Ideally, you get as many players as possible that both hit homers and steal bases with a good average.

    Or if they do not steal or they do not hit homers, you need to target the players that are capable of providing elite value in one or the other and they have a good average to make up for them lacking in a different category.

    This is why players like Junior Caminero are an early round asset, despite being a negative in the steals category. He can get you 40+ homers with a good average.

    You also want to target players hitting in prime spots in the batting order. Lineup placement matters for runs and RBI as those at the top of the lineup are surrounded by their team’s best players so they are likely to get driven in if they are on base or are likely to have runners on base for them to drive in when they are up to the plate.

    Drafting pitching in the early rounds is a risk. Year-to-year, there is major volatility when it comes to pitching.

    First, they get hurt more often than hitters and miss more time when they are hurt.

    Second, the performance in general is volatile. Look at pitchers like Logan Webb, Bryan Woo and Paul Skenes. These arms were thought to be elite starting pitchers and, well, they were not in 2026.

    In standard 12-team leagues, I recommend heavily waiting until at least the fifth round to take your first starter, only breaking that rule if a clear value presents itself (IE if someone like Chris Sale falls to the third round, you should probably take him).

    I also would fade closers in the early rounds, generally avoiding them like the plague.

    Closer values are way more volatile than their starting counter parts. Their samples are small game-to-game, meaning that in less than one inning,sometimes even one pitch, can lead to a ratio-destroying outing.. A few bad outings (innings) can lead to them losing their closer jobs.

    A few bad innings won’t cause a starter to lose their job. A few bad at-bats won’t lead to a hitter being benched.

    IN ONE-CATCHER LEAGUES – Taking a catcher in the early rounds is also risky, but if you do decide to snag one, it will need to be a catcher that you are confident will get at-bats outside of the catcher spot.

    Think guys like Cal Raleigh, William Contreras, Hunter Goodman.

    If you miss out on the top dudes that play every day, then you absolutely be fading the catcher spot until late in drafts. Most other catchers have built-in days off that limit their volume and upside.

    Outside pitching and catcher, you should be ‘position agnostic’ in the early rounds. Don’t reach for a second baseman or third baseman in these early rounds because you think the position is shallow. If you take someone in the second, third or fourth rounds, they need to have that level of value.

    This means taking the best/most valuable player available, regardless of position.

    Now, don’t go drafting 3 first baseman.

    But getting 2 outfielders or corner infielders (or even 3 OFs in five-outfield formats), in the first few rounds is fine, if they provide that value.

    Draft Strategy – Middle rounds

    This is where you need to start filling the holes in your roster, and if you followed my logic above, these rounds are filled with starting pitchers.

    Here are a list of starters going beyond pick 75 in early NFBC ADP (Today is November 15) that I think you can target to help you build a legit pitching staff that can compete if you did fade the position.

    • Logan Henderson
    • Bryan Woo
    • Max Fried
    • Hunter Brown
    • Jacob deGrom
    • Reid Detmers

    Taking around three of these arms in the middle rounds (keep in mind these ADPs are inflated in this early ADP data as the leagues drafting right now are draft-and-holds where pitching is more valued, so a lot of these arms will be available in the middle rounds in typical redraft roto leagues in Feb./Mar).

    Even going deeper in the ADP are arms like Carlos Rodan, Taj Bradely, Michael King, Sonny Gray, Christian Scott (BUY!).

    Each of them are examples of arms that can provide similar value to the top arms, at least similar enough that you can still be extremely competitive in pitching categories without wasting a second-round pick on Chris Sale.

    These are also the rounds to pick up at least one closer.

    Many managers will take the Mason Millers and Cade Smiths of the world in the top four-to-six rounds.

    Let ’em.

    You can be competitive in saves without paying that price.

    And ultimately, that is the one category that these arms really provide immense value in.

    Yeah, Miller will get you 100 Ks and 70 innings of great ratios, but it’s just 70 innings of those ratios. That not even a half a season for a starting pitcher.

    So, the value is capped and limited for closers.

    Wait and target these dudes later

    • Trevor Megill
    • Edwin Diaz
    • Daniel Palencia
    • Aroldis Chapman
    • Andres Munoz

    For hitters, you still want to try and find hitters that are providing you as much value across all the categories, but that become less and less likely as the draft goes.

    This means you will need to have a sense of what categories you are lacking.

    Shameless plug alert – If you are a FantasyPass member, we will create a draft tracker so you don’t need to guess where you stand across all categories. The tracker will keep up for you.

    If you don’t, then you will need to pay attention to the strengths and weaknesses of your team.

    Not only do you need to target the positions you don’t already have, you need to target category production that fits your team.

    Want to get access to the rest of Paul’s article? You’ll need to have a FANTASYPASS membership. Click here to learn more and sign up! Premium Access Required

    Come join us at SportsEthos by filling out an application by clicking here
    Click here to join us on Discord!
    Follow us on X by clicking her