-
February 17, 2026, 8:00 amWelcome to the Williamson 300!
These are my second crack at this rankings thing and I am as confident as ever in that they can truly help you win.
I have many names on here that are right along their market price. I got names that are well below market price. And, of course, so many names well above market price.
Before we get to the ranks, let me explain how to use them.
First, this is for standard category leagues.
5×5.
Mostly geared toward roto formats but head-to-head category managers should find this list extremely valuable as well (maybe fading some injury prone players and some platoon dudes). But I try to bake a player’s platoon/injury risk into the ranks.
Next, these ranks are based on how I think they’ll finish overall. This means to note that I have catchers and pitchers (closers especially) pushed a bit down as that is their value. But that does not mean that is where you draft them. Keep an eye on your draft room. if there is a run on certain positions (especially those pitchers and catchers), you may have to reach in order to avoid having a black hole on your roster.
Also, this is for 12-team, one-catcher setups.
If you are in a deeper format, you need to –
- Again, I repeat… Keep an eye on your draft room. I would recommend pushing up pitchers at least a round or two in deeper than 12-team formats, but if you get into your draft, keep an eye to see how fast arms are being drafted. Especially closers. A lot of times, managers aggressively draft arms early and that will force you to reach beyond the recommendation of these ranks, even beyond my recommended 1-2 round push.Â
- Two-catcher league? You gotta push those catchers up at least a couple of rounds as well. I push a lot of catchers down the overall ranks because of the playing time. Full time catchers that don’t get DH/1B at-bats will max out at 450-500 plate appearances. These ranks will reflect that. But, again, these ranks should not dictate the literal order you should draft them.
- And questions? Hit me up on X here
- Or on Blue Sky here
A combination of these ranks and some in-draft savvy/ will go a long way toward you winning your league.
My top-50 are free to all but to get access to the full list, you will need to have an MLB FantasyPass membership.
TOP-50 FANTASY PLAYERS (ON THE HOUSE)
Rank Name Position Team Analysis 1 Shohei Ohtani UT LAD Yes, Ohtani will get more steals and has the same power potential as Judge. That puts him at 1. 2 Aaron Judge OF1 NYY He is one of the greatest of all time and is the no brainer for the top (outfield) spot here. 3 Juan Soto OF2 NYM He has finally improved his lift to maximize his incredible power and now steals are something for him. May not get to 30+ again but he should be line for enough to put him in this spot. 4 Bobby Witt Jr SS/MI1 KCR Home run total drop looks flukey as he has the same BRL/HH/EV/Lift from previous 30+ HR seasons. Should be an elite five-cat stud. 5 Jose Ramirez 3B/CI1 CLE Consistent and steady first round production year in and year out and at a shallow third base position. 6 Ronald Acuna OF3 ATL Performance in Winter Ball, especially in steals, gives confidence in his health as that is only thing standing in his way from being back to an elite fantasy asset. 7 Gunnar Henderson SS/MI2 BAL All power metrics the same except for his barrel rate that was impacted by shoulder injury. Believe he will be back to 30+ homers in a great Oriole lineup. 8 Kyle Tucker OF4 LAD He is going as a late first round, early second round pick and that makes him an abslute steal. New Dodger home means he can easily set career marks for Runs and RBI. 9 Julio Rodrguez OF5 SEA Entering his age 25 season means he actually has room to grow and get better. 10 Tarik Skubal SP1 DET It isn't quite up for debate that Skubal is the SP1. I think if any of these 'big 3' are available near your turn in 12-team leagues, you can take one here. 11 Paul Skenes SP2 PIT Improving team gives him the wins he needs to overtake Crochet 12 Garrett Crochet SP3 BOS He really is 1C to Skubal and Skenes 1A/1B 13 Elly De La Cruz SS/MI3 CIN Major power outage in the second half of last year but dude still has loads of talent and is a threat to be the top bat in fantasy. 14 Fernando Tatis OF6 SDP An improved hit tool entering age 27 season makes Tatis a pretty attractive fantasy asset. 15 Junior Caminero 3B/CI2 TBR Some fear of him going to the Trop but has slowly improved his lift and pull to go with elite quality of contact metrics to allow his power to play most any where. 16 Vladimir Gurerro 1B/CI3 TOR Still can't lift the ball enough to put him over Caminero but has proven to be an elite producer worthy of this spot in the ranks 17 Kyle Schwarber UT PHI The elite power and run production is so good we don't care bout the possible average hit. 18 Pete Alonso 1B/CI4 NYM This Baltimore lineup will afford him ample RBI opportunities as he has been a consistent source of pwoer through the years. 19 Pete Crow-Armstrong OF7 CHC He showed improved contact inside the zone as he showed me enough in the plate discipline department for me to rank him aggressively. 20 Jazz Chisholm 2B/3B, MI4/CI5 NYY The potential for 40/40 can let managers overlook a low average. 21 Jackson Chourio OF8 MIL Can he finally get to 650+ plate appearances to rack up the counting stats to blow this ranking out of the water? 22 Zach Neto SS/MI5 LAA Elite in-zone contact with great quality of contact numbers makes me overlook some hit tool issues. 23 Yordan Alvarez UT HOU Yeah, injuries are a concern but his metrics all point to him being the same hitter he always was, even after returning from the injuries last year. 24 Brent Rooker OF9 ATH Elite power metrics as he improved his contact rate to over 70% in a good lineup with a good average to boot. 25 Logan Gilbert SP4 SEA 50% whiff on splitter, 30%+ on slider/curve, Splitter should get back to returning more ground balls. 26 Matt Olson 1B/CI7 ATL Good average, elite power, plays every day. 27 Rafael Devers 1B/CI8 SFG His power metrics are more than elite enough to let his power play in San Fran 28 Trea Turner SS/MI6 PHI Won't take a major leap of logic to think his BRL will go back to league average to allow him to get to 20+ homers to go with elite steals, counting stats and batting average. 29 Chris Sale SP5 ATL Just consistently performs like an ace. 30 Cole Ragans SP6 KCR 47 whiffs in three starts back from shoulder injury to close out 2025. Not worried about the shoulder. 31 Roman Anthony OF10 BOS Showed excellent plate discipine and elite power metrics as he is primed to breakout. 32 Francisco Lindor SS/MI7 NYM Elite first round production, year in and year out, but injury to start camp warrants a fade down the ranks 33 Corbin Carroll OF11 ARI A more aggressive approach at the plate unlocked full power potential in 2025. Now surgery on hand to open camp should give managers pause and fades him down the ranks. 34 Byron Buxton OF12 MIN He showed us he can stay healthy and his tools did not diminish. Poor team context keeps him ranked a bit lower than I'd like. 35 Manny Machado 3B/CI9 SDP Death. Taxes. And Manny Machado being a rock solid fantasy producer. 36 Ketel Marte 2B/MI8 ARI Not get to 600 PA the last two great seasons but still should provide plenty of homers, counting stats and solid average. 37 Jackson Merrill OF13 SDP A full seaon of health should see at least some speed return as his power metrics are looking better and better. 38 Freddie Freeman 1B/CI10 LAD The elite team context keeps him in the top 10 of the corner infielders 39 Austin Riley 3B/CI11 ATL Despite the injuries, the metrics still point to Riley being awesome. Just gotta stay healthy. 40 Bryce Harper 1B/CI12 PHI Steady power production but can he get to 600 PA to help him accumulate runs and RBI? 41 Vinnie Pasquantino 1B/CI13 KCR Elite power metrics with a great hit tool as he is one more elite campaign from being a top 10 CI 42 Hunter Brown SP7 HOU Elite swing and miss on four-seamer, knuckle curve pitch keeps improving and well beyond an elite offering. Tons of ground balls and soft contact. 43 Yoshinobu Yamamoto SP8 LAD October usage plus WBC instead of a slow and steady spring scares me. He would be the number four without the usage concern. 44 Bryan Woo SP9 SEA A second Mariner arm in the top-10. Elite swing and miss on 4-seamer and slider/sweeper. Great BB%. Has the stuff to improve. 45 Cris Sanchez SP10 PHI Improving whiff on change/slider but hadn't been that good of a K arm prior to 2025's 26%. Need to see again b/f I aggressively rank 46 Max Fried SP11 NYY Steady Eddie. Consistent low-end SP1 production year in and year out. 47 James Wood OF14 WSN Horrible hit tool in second half gives me tons of pause. Will need to see him produce again to be fully in for 2027. 48 Wyatt Langford OF15 TEX Real nice power and speed combo but home park and a 'meh' team context keeps him a bit low on the list. 49 CJ Abrams SS/MI9 WSN Good lift and pull gives him solid power floor, improving young lineup helps the counting stats to go with solid average and 30 steals. 50 Mookie Betts SS/MI10 LAD Great end to last year gives some faith the illness impacted him hard. Should still be a great source of counting stats and average with at least some homers. Want to get access to the full UTIL rankings and Williamson 300? You’ll need to have an MLB FantasyPass membership. Click here to learn more and sign up!
Premium Access RequiredClick here to join us on Discord! And Follow us on Twitter by clicking here
Come join us at SportsEthos by filling out an application by clicking here.ÂFollow Paul on X here and Blue Sky here
