Middleton/Williams side for me. In 9 cat, Morant is less valuable. More so when you're punting points which is also the main category contribution that Hunter provides. 

Pinging Rhett to this thread instead of the other. Oops. Saw the other one before I saw this one.

Posted by: @tnshiners

↑

16team Dynasty 9 Cat H2h with 8 starters (all these players are rostered for this season and the next 2 seasons)

 

Punting 3's and Points.

 

1. Ja Morant and De'Andre Hunter

for

2. Kris Middleton and Rob Williams 

 

So this is one of the most interesting kinds of trades for me, I love it. You have a great player who really doesn't fit your build, and you're targeting someone in Timelord who would be elite in your build plus a huge upgrade of Hunter to Middleton. Sounds great!

Except when it comes to top talent, you just can't take that kind of hit, and valuing dynasty players based on punt values is how you end up losing out unless you're going to win it all this year.

As long as the two sides I have in front of me are top-20+170ish vs two top-60ish, I'm keeping the top-20 and looking for more of a straight swap that fits better. Maybe a Scottie Barnes, Dejounte Murray, or someone like Josh Giddey with a bit more added on that side.

@rhett-bauer thanks for the reply! Really appreciate it! What about someone like Garland for Morant?

@tnshiners that works! Pretty lateral as far as the build goes, but that's the kind of value I'd be looking for(just as my dynasty ranks say 😉)

In the same dynasty league, I was offered Kyle Andersen for Jalen McDaniels. What do you all think of the short and long term potential of these two? 

That's an interesting one. Personally with someone like SloMo, I'm confident in what he is. Pretty much no upside with him outside of a couple weeks a year where there's an injury.

Jalen is a higher risk since he's a second round pick that really hasn't solidified himself until some of last year+this one with the Bridges situation...but I feel like his upside is higher as a younger+more versatile player than SloMo

@rhett-bauer  circling back to this with another trade offer dynasty league. My Ja for Giddey and Bane?