That's tough. You could argue that Harris is the best player in the deal if you're worried enough about the injury that Middleton is playing through. This is a trade where I think league depth matters, though. If this were a 10 or 12 team league I might accept it, and take on the safer early-round player right now in Harris, and gain the roster spot to stream with or chase upside with. But in a 16 teamer, that roster spot is a lot less valuable, and a player like Redick is much further away from the fringes--a legit depth piece. So in this situation I think I'd stick with Middleton and Redick.

Yeah, pretty fair!

I'd prefer Middleton. That said, if you need the depth, the deal is fair.